After two long marriages and unexpected new beginnings, Sam and Cindy found love when they least expected it; even though their paths had nearly crossed for years. They lived in the same community for almost two decades, and Cindy’s children had even trick-or-treated at Sam’s house. But it wasn’t until they connected on a dating app and shared their first date on Halloween that everything fell into place.

Their story is proof that sometimes love isn’t about finding the right person right away, it’s about finding the right person at exactly the right time.

Now, Sam and Cindy are competing to become America’s Favorite Couple. Explore their story, get to know the couple behind the smiles, and cast your vote to help them reach the finish line together.